38+
HVAC companies competing
in your service area
81%
Of Google searches where
Collins shows up
7/10
Highland Searches
in Google Maps (while open)
112
Collins' reviews vs. 2,000+
for the top competitor
What Does This All Mean?
When someone in Highland, Munster, or Schererville searches Google for "AC installation near me" or "furnace repair," there are several places a business can show up:
1. Paid Ads — Sponsored results at the very top. Competitors who pay for Google Ads or Local Services Ads ("Google Guaranteed") show up here. Collins is not running any paid ads currently.
2. The Local Pack & Google Maps — The top 3 businesses shown with the map. This is where most homeowners look first and where most phone calls come from. As of March 31, 2026, Collins is now appearing in the Local Pack for 7 of 28 tracked keywords during business hours, including #1 for "furnace repair Highland Indiana." The listing is a Service Area Business (no public address), and the review count is still 10x lower than the leaders — but the GBP optimization and weekly posting are paying off.
3. Organic Results — The regular list of websites below the map. Collins shows up here for 81% of searches, which is actually very strong and gives you a solid foundation to build on.
4. AI Search Results — Google's AI answers, ChatGPT, and Siri are how more and more homeowners search. Collins shows up in AI results for Highland searches but not yet for other cities. This is the next growth area.
The biggest gap between Collins and the top competitors is Google reviews. The companies that dominate the local pack have 1,000+ reviews. Collins has 112. Google uses review count as one of the main factors for deciding who gets into the top spots.
Key Findings
The most important things we found during this research:
🎉
Collins Is Now in the Google Local Pack
As of March 31, 2026 (checked during business hours at 10:48 AM CT), Collins appears in the Local Pack for 7 of 28 tracked keywords. Highlights: #1 for "furnace repair Highland Indiana," #2 for "new furnace Highland IN," and #3 for AC repair, furnace installation, furnace replacement, heating and cooling, and new AC searches. Previous checks ran after business hours and showed zero pack appearances — this confirms that business hours visibility is significantly better. The review gap (112 vs. 1,000+) and SAB listing are still limiting factors, but Collins is breaking through.
⚠️
You Need More Google Reviews
Collins has 112 Google reviews. Your top 3 local competitors each have over 1,000. Google heavily favors businesses with more reviews when deciding who shows up on the map. Every happy customer who leaves a review helps close this gap.
👀
Customers in 3 Cities Can't Find You Online
In Schererville, Munster, and St. John, Collins doesn't appear in the top 10 Google results for any search term we tested. That means homeowners in those cities searching for HVAC services will never see Collins. These are high-value markets you're missing out on.
✅
Strong Position in Highland & Dyer
Collins ranks in the top 3 for most searches in Highland (your home turf) and you're the #1 result for furnace installation in both Highland and Dyer. You have a solid foundation — the goal is to expand this strength to the other cities.
Google Reviews: How Collins Compares
Google reviews are the #1 factor in who shows up on the map. Here's where Collins stands compared to the competition:
* King Heating is mainly a Chicago company — NWI is a side market for them. Review counts verified via Birdeye, March 2026.
Your Position in Each City
How Collins ranks in each service area and who's winning each market. "Organic" means the regular website results. "Local Pack" is the top-3 businesses shown with the map. There are also paid ad slots and AI-generated results.
Highland (Home Base)
STRONG
Google results: Rank #1-2 for most searches
Local Pack: Collins #1 for furnace repair, #2-3 for others
Collins in Google Maps for 7 of 10 Highland searches (business hours)
Dyer
STRONG
Google results: #1 for furnace install, #3-5 others
Local Pack: Houston Htg #1, Earl's #2, HVAC Rios #3
Main threats: Williamson, EcoEdge, All American
Hammond
MODERATE
Google results: Rank #4-9 — shows up but not near the top
Local Pack: Comfort One, Mr. Freeze, Budd Mechanical
Market leaders: King Heating, Polar, South Suburban
Griffith
WEAK
Google results: Rank #7-10 — near the bottom of page 1
Local Pack: Meyer's #1, Centsible #2, After Hours #3
Meyer's (since 1951) dominates this city
Munster
NOT VISIBLE
Google results: Not on page 1 for any search
Local Pack: K&M Heating #1, POPA #2, Siemer #3
Leaders: Williamson, Budd Mechanical, Earl's
Schererville
NOT VISIBLE
Google results: Not on page 1 for any search
Local Pack: Siemer #1, Earl's #2, STAT HVAC #3
STAT HVAC completely owns this market
St. John
NOT VISIBLE
Google results: Not on page 1 for any search
Leaders: EcoEdge, True Quality, Williamson, Cliff's
High-income area — big opportunity
Collins Rankings: March 31, 2026
We searched 28 things a homeowner might type into Google, checked at 10:48 AM on a weekday. Collins shows up in regular results for 21 of them, and in the map results for 7.
Google Maps Results — Highland (7 of 10)
- furnace repair Highland Indiana: Organic #2, Pack #1
- new furnace Highland IN: Organic #1, Pack #2
- AC repair Highland Indiana: Organic #2, Pack #3
- furnace installation Highland Indiana: Organic #1, Pack #3
- furnace replacement Highland Indiana: Organic #1, Pack #3
- heating and cooling Highland Indiana: Organic #2, Pack #3
- new AC Highland IN: Organic #6, Pack #3
Organic Rankings (21/28 keywords)
- #1 for: heater repair, air conditioner repair, furnace replacement, AC installation, air conditioner replacement, whole home air purifier, HVAC contractor Highland, Collins brand, AC repair near me, HVAC contractor near me Highland
- #2 for: furnace repair Highland, AC repair Highland, heating & cooling Highland, furnace repair near me
- #3 for: HVAC contractor Dyer
- #4 for: HVAC contractor Griffith, HVAC contractor Hammond
- #6 for: new AC Highland
- #9 for: indoor air quality Highland
- Not ranking: Schererville, St. John, Munster (zero presence), "furnace not working," "AC not cooling"
Who Shows Up Most on Google
We ran 26 Google searches a homeowner might type (like "AC installation Highland Indiana"). This table shows how often each company appeared:
| # |
Company |
Showed Up In |
Strongest Cities |
Threat Level |
| 1 |
Williamson Heating & Cooling |
23 of 26 (88%) |
Everywhere — has a page for every city |
Top Threat |
| 2 |
▶ Collins Heating & Cooling |
21 of 26 (81%) |
Highland, Dyer — missing Schererville |
YOU |
| 3 |
Polar Heating & AC |
14 of 26 (54%) |
Hammond, Highland, Munster, St. John |
High |
| 3 |
EcoEdge Systems |
14 of 26 (54%) |
Highland, Dyer, St. John, Hammond |
High |
| 3 |
Siemer HVAC |
14 of 26 (54%) |
Highland, Hammond, Schererville, Munster |
High |
| 6 |
Meyer's Companies |
12 of 26 (46%) |
Griffith (dominant), Hammond, Munster |
High |
| 7 |
True Quality HVAC |
10 of 26 (38%) |
Highland, Griffith, Dyer, St. John |
Moderate |
| 8 |
STAT HVAC |
8 of 26 (31%) |
Schererville (dominant), Munster |
Moderate |
| 8 |
Cliff's Heating & AC |
8 of 26 (31%) |
Schererville, Dyer, St. John |
Moderate |
| 8 |
Earl's Heating |
8 of 26 (31%) |
Schererville, Munster |
Moderate |
| 11 |
Naughton Mechanical |
7 of 26 |
St. John, Highland, Dyer |
Low |
| 11 |
Struven Heating |
7 of 26 |
Highland, Munster, Griffith |
Low |
| 11 |
Comfort Aire Inc |
7 of 26 |
Griffith, Schererville, Munster |
Low |
Your Top Competitors — Detailed Profiles
Here's what each major competitor has going for them — their website, reviews, services, and what makes them stand out:
Williamson Heating & Cooling
Family-Owned
Top Threat
Google Visibility#1 — shows up in 88% of searches
Why They WinHas a dedicated webpage for every single city
WeaknessReview count not publicly prominent
City Pages for Every MarketWordPress
Siemer Heating, Cooling & Plumbing
Est. 1987 • Highland, IN
Top Threat
Google Reviews★ 4.9 — 2,021 reviews
ServicesHVAC + Plumbing + Commercial
Website Size50+ pages, 27 city pages
Specials Running6 active promotions right now
BBBA+ Accredited since 2008
CarrierNATE CertifiedPresident's Award+PlumbingActive Specials
POPA Heating & Cooling
Est. 1968 • Highland, IN
Top Threat
Google Reviews★ 4.9 — 1,355 reviews
ServicesHVAC + Commercial + 24/7 Emergency
Local Pack#1 in Highland for most searches
BBBA+ rated (not accredited)
TraneNATE CertifiedDistinguished DealerMembership Plan
Earl's Heating & Air Conditioning
Est. 1975 • Schererville, IN
High Threat
Google Reviews★ 4.8 — 1,369 reviews
ServicesHVAC + IAQ + Commercial + Blog
Specials Running6 specials + financing offers
BBBA+ Accredited since 2002
TraneNATE + EPA CertifiedActive Blog6 Active Specials
King Heating, Cooling & Plumbing
Est. 1968 • Chicago Area
High Threat
Google Reviews★ 4.7 — 4,315 reviews
ServicesHVAC + Plumbing + Duct Cleaning
Website Size50+ pages with city landing pages
NoteMainly Chicago — NWI is secondary
CarrierNATE Certified+Plumbing24/7 No Extra Charge
Meyer's Companies, Inc.
Est. 1951 • Griffith, IN
High Threat
Google Reviews★ 4.7 — ~333 reviews
ServicesHVAC + Plumbing + Electrical + Generators
GriffithCompletely dominates this city
Weakness2.0 stars on Yelp (14 of 20 are 1-star)
Bryant+Plumbing+Electrical+GeneratorsVIP $15/mo
EcoEdge Systems
Rising Competitor
High Threat
Google VisibilityShows in 54% of searches
SEO StrategyAggressive city-by-city pages
Key DangerRapidly gaining ground everywhere
City Pages SEOGrowing Fast
STAT HVAC
Schererville, IN
Moderate
Google Reviews★ 5.0 — 160+ reviews
DominanceOwns Schererville completely
WeaknessWix limits how high they can rank
Ducane / ArmstrongWix (Weakness)Online Store
Polar Heating & AC
60+ Years in Business
High Threat
Google VisibilityShows in 54% of searches
Strongest CitiesHammond, Highland, Munster, St. John
NATE Certified24/7 Emergency60+ Years
Armando's Heating & Cooling
Highland, IN
Moderate
WebsiteNO website (directories only)
Google Reviews★ 4.7 — 86 reviews
Local Pack#2 in Highland despite fewer reviews
⚠ Red FlagResidential address, 3 businesses same location
GMB Violation SuspectedNo WebsiteNo BBB
What Your Competitors Are Doing That's Working
Things the top companies are doing to win customers online. Green checkmarks = Collins does this. Red X = Collins doesn't do this yet.
| What They Do |
Who's Doing It |
Why It Works |
Collins? |
| A webpage for each city they serve |
Williamson, EcoEdge, Siemer, Summers |
Google shows the most relevant local page for each city |
Has pages, needs more content |
| Constantly asking for reviews |
Siemer (2,000+), POPA (1,300+), Earl's (1,300+) |
More reviews = higher on the map = more calls |
112 reviews — 10x behind |
| Running specials & deals |
Siemer (6 active), Earl's (6), Meyer's, Lansing |
Creates urgency — "I should call now" |
Has a specials page |
| Maintenance membership plans |
POPA, Siemer, Meyer's ($15/mo), King |
Steady monthly income + keeps customers coming back |
Doesn't have one |
| Blog with helpful articles |
Siemer, Earl's, Summers, King |
Google rewards websites that regularly add useful content |
No blog |
| 24/7 emergency service |
POPA, King, Polar, Summers |
Catches customers who search at night and weekends |
Not offered |
| Online appointment booking |
POPA, King, Summers |
Customers can book without calling — less friction |
Contact form only |
| Financing options shown on website |
POPA (Wells Fargo), Earl's (18-mo), Siemer (0%) |
Removes the "I can't afford it right now" objection |
Not offered |
| BBB Accreditation |
Siemer, Earl's, Meyer's, Lansing, STAT |
Trust badge that shows in search results |
A+ rated (not accredited) |
Website Features: Who Has What
What each competitor's website offers that Collins' doesn't (yet):
| Company |
Website Tool |
Pages |
Blog |
Book Online |
Chat |
City Pages |
| Siemer | WordPress | 50+ | ✅ | ✅ | — | 27 cities |
| King Heating | WordPress | 50+ | ✅ | ✅ | — | 20+ cities |
| Earl's | WordPress | 30+ | ✅ | ✅ | — | — |
| Meyer's | WordPress | 25-30 | ✅ | — | — | 20+ cities |
| Williamson | WordPress | 30+ | — | — | — | Every city |
| POPA | WordPress | 15-20 | — | ✅ | — | — |
| Summers | WordPress | 100+ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 25 locations |
| Lansing | WordPress | 30+ | — | ✅ | — | 9 cities |
| STAT HVAC | Wix | 15-20 | — | — | — | — |
| EcoEdge | WordPress | 30+ | — | — | — | All cities |
| ▶ Collins | WordPress / Divi | 17 | — | — | — | 6 cities |
Where Competitors Show Up Across the Internet
Customers don't just check Google — they look at Yelp, BBB, Facebook, and other sites. Here's where everyone has a presence:
| Company |
Google |
Yelp |
BBB |
Facebook |
Angi |
Nextdoor |
Awards |
| Siemer |
★ 4.9 (2,021) |
Listed |
A+ Accredited |
Active |
4.8 |
✅ |
Carrier President's Award |
| POPA |
★ 4.9 (1,355) |
14 reviews |
A+ (not accred.) |
92% recommend |
4.9 |
✅ |
Top Rated Local #2 IN |
| Earl's |
★ 4.8 (1,369) |
Listed |
A+ Accredited |
Active |
4.7 |
✅ |
Trane Distinguished Dealer |
| King |
★ 4.7 (4,315) |
3.5 (122 rev.) |
A+ Accredited |
~70 reviews |
4.3 |
— |
#1 Plumbing Southland |
| Meyer's |
★ 4.7 (~333) |
2.0 stars |
A+ Accredited |
Active |
4.7 |
✅ |
75 years |
| Summers |
★ ~4.6 |
2.3 stars (216 rev.) |
A+ Accredited |
Active |
4.6 |
— |
Best Pick 4.9 |
| ▶ Collins |
★ 4.8 (112) |
18 reviews |
A+ (not accred.) |
Limited |
5.0 |
11 Faves |
None found |
💡
Directory & Platform Presence
Collins has profiles on Google, Yelp, BBB, Angi, Facebook, and Nextdoor. Platforms like HomeAdvisor, Thumbtack, Houzz, Birdeye, and Top Rated Local are paid services — worth evaluating ROI on a case-by-case basis, but not necessarily gaps that need filling. The biggest priority is maximizing the free platforms Collins is already on, especially Google.
💪
Competitor Weakness: Meyer's & Summers Have Terrible Yelp Reviews
Meyer's has a 2.0-star Yelp rating (14 of 20 reviews are 1-star). Summers has a 2.3-star rating (216 bad reviews). Homeowners researching these companies will see those ratings — that's an opportunity for Collins to be the better-reviewed alternative.
Suspicious Competitor Practices
During our research, we found competitors that may be breaking Google's rules to get an unfair advantage in the map results:
🚨
Armando's Heating & Cooling — Possible Fake Business Address
Listed at a residential house (8204 Kennedy Ave, Highland) with 3 completely unrelated businesses at the same address. Ranks #2 on the map in Highland despite having only 86 reviews (Collins has 112). This likely violates Google's rules and could be reported.
⚠️
Economy Heating & Cooling — Wrong Address on Google
Their Google listing shows 9031 Grace St (a house that sold for $7,900 — possibly vacant). Their real address is 2928 E 4th Pl, Highland. Using a wrong address can unfairly boost map rankings.
👀
American Heating & Cooling — Can't Verify This Business Exists
Shows 99 reviews with a perfect 5.0 rating and appears at #3 on the Highland map, but has zero online presence outside of Google — no website, no BBB, no Angi, no social media, no address listed. This business cannot be independently verified.
Equipment Brands in the Market
Which HVAC equipment brands each competitor sells and installs:
| Brand | Sold By | Dealer Level |
| Carrier | Siemer, King, Lansing Heating | Factory Authorized (Siemer has President's Award) |
| Trane | POPA, Earl's | Distinguished Dealer / Comfort Specialist |
| Bryant | Meyer's | Factory Authorized Dealer |
| Armstrong Air | Collins, STAT HVAC | Authorized Dealer |
| Ducane | STAT HVAC | Installer |
The NWI market is dominated by Carrier and Trane. Collins' Armstrong Air position is less crowded — fewer competitors, but the brand is less well-known to homeowners.
The Bottom Line
✅ Where Collins Wins
- Strong in Highland & Dyer — top 3 for most searches
- #1 in Google Maps for furnace repair Highland — showing up for 7 of 10 Highland searches during business hours
- #1 for furnace installation in Highland and Dyer
- Shows up in 81% of searches across all markets
- Excellent reputation — 4.8 stars, A+ BBB
- "Repairs first" approach that customers love
- Talk to the tech directly — no middleman
- Already has city pages for 6 service areas
- Google Business Profile is well-maintained with weekly posts
❌ Where Collins Falls Behind
- No public address means Google Maps results are limited to Highland only — not Griffith, Munster, Hammond, or other cities (business hours only)
- 112 reviews vs. 1,000-2,000 for the top 3 (reviews dropped off for 2 years)
- Invisible in 3 cities (Schererville, Munster, St. John)
- Only 17 website pages vs. 50+ for top competitors
- No blog, no online booking, no financing
- No maintenance plan for recurring revenue
- No advertising or paid lead channels running currently
- Not showing up in AI answers outside of Highland (yet)
Top 5 Things to Do Right Now
- Close the review gap — Collins shows up in Google Maps for 7 of 10 Highland searches during business hours (including #1 for furnace repair). Going from 112 to 250+ reviews is the fastest way to hold those positions and start appearing for more.
- Set up a review generation system — Text every happy customer a direct link after each job. A tool like Podium or NiceJob automates this. Siemer gets 30-50 new reviews/month with Podium — that's the playbook.
- Build out the website for Schererville, Munster, and St. John — You need strong, unique content for each city. Williamson shows up everywhere because they have a dedicated page for every town.
- Strengthen the AC installation and furnace installation pages — Collins has these pages but drops from #2 to #4 for installation-specific searches. Expanding the content, adding more customer proof points, and tightening the on-page SEO could close that gap.
- Report the suspicious Google listings — Armando's residential address and American Heating's unverifiable profile are taking map spots from legitimate businesses like Collins.
How Fast Are Competitors Getting Reviews?
It's not just about how many reviews you have — it's about how fast you're getting new ones. Companies that actively ask for reviews grow much faster:
| Company |
Total Reviews |
Est. New Reviews/Month |
Review Tool |
Responds to Reviews? |
| King Heating |
4,315 |
50-80/month |
Manual (no tool detected) |
✅ Yes — professional responses |
| Siemer HVAC |
2,021 |
30-50/month |
Podium (confirmed) |
✅ Yes — Podium automated |
| Earl's Heating |
1,369 |
15-25/month |
None detected |
✅ Yes — owner responds |
| POPA Heating |
1,355 |
15-30/month |
None detected |
Unknown |
| Centsible HVAC |
602 |
8-15/month |
Direct Google link on site |
Unknown |
| STAT HVAC |
160+ |
3-5/month |
None detected |
Unknown |
| Williamson |
137 |
2-4/month |
None detected |
Unknown |
| ▶ Collins |
112 |
Low |
None |
Unknown |
| Armando's |
86 |
2-4/month |
None detected |
Unknown |
| Meyer's |
~8 |
<1/month |
None |
N/A |
💡
Siemer Uses Podium — That's Why They're Growing So Fast
Siemer is the only competitor we found using a professional review management tool (Podium). Their website previously showed 1,405 reviews — they're now at 2,021. That's roughly 600 new reviews in about 12-18 months. A tool like Podium, NiceJob, or Birdeye automatically texts customers after each job and asks for a review. This is the fastest way to close the review gap.
⚠️
Meyer's = Cautionary Tale
Meyer's has been in business for 75 years but only has 8 Google reviews. Proof that longevity alone doesn't build your online presence. Without actively asking for reviews, even a great business becomes invisible online.
Social Media & Content Marketing
Where competitors are active online beyond their website and Google listing. Links go directly to their profiles:
FB = Facebook, IG = Instagram, YT = YouTube, X = Twitter/X, LI = LinkedIn, ND = Nextdoor. No competitor was found on TikTok — wide open opportunity.
📺
King Heating Runs TV Commercials
King Heating is the only competitor with TV advertising (tracked on iSpot.tv). They also acquired Hollaway-Meyer's in Hammond — a company that served Hammond since 1927. This puts a well-funded, multi-brand competitor directly in Collins' service area. King now has 7 acquired companies, 50-200 employees, and signing bonuses for new techs.
📸
Where to Focus: Facebook & Google Are What Matter
For NW Indiana homeowners ages 45–60, Facebook and Google are the only platforms that drive real business. Collins already has a Facebook page (356 likes). Instagram is noise for this market — the target customers aren't browsing Instagram for HVAC contractors. A blog on the new website would help Google rank Collins higher, and Meyer's proves that consistent helpful articles (300+ posts) can build visibility even with barely any reviews.
Website Speed Comparison
Google ranks faster sites higher. Over half of visitors leave if a site takes more than 3 seconds to load on a phone.
| Company |
Load Time |
Verdict |
| POPA Heating |
0.50s |
Fastest |
| Williamson |
0.79s |
Good |
| Siemer |
0.80s |
Good |
| ▶ Collins |
0.84s |
OK — current site builder adds unnecessary weight |
| Earl's |
1.07s |
Acceptable |
| King Heating |
1.68s |
Slow |
| Meyer's |
1.87s |
Slowest |
The new Collins site will be in the "Good" range or better. Faster site = higher on Google = more calls from phones.
Who's Growing? Hiring & Expansion Signals
Job postings tell us which competitors are expanding and investing in growth:
| Company |
Hiring? |
Open Positions |
What It Means |
| King Heating |
Yes — Aggressively |
Multiple HVAC techs + installers, signing bonuses |
7 acquisitions, 50-200 employees, expanding into NWI |
| Earl's Heating |
Yes |
Lead Installer ($70K-$150K), Service Tech |
Growing — competitive pay signals investment |
| POPA Heating |
Yes |
Service Tech ($20-$27/hr + benefits) |
Expanding capacity |
| Siemer |
Careers listed on Indeed |
No specific current listings confirmed |
Stable |
| ▶ Collins |
No listings found |
— |
Owner-operated, stable |
| Meyer's |
No listings found |
— |
Stable |
Advertising & Marketing Intelligence
Who's spending money on advertising, who's managing their marketing, and how much they're likely investing:
| Company |
Marketing Agency |
Est. Ad Spend (to Google/FB) |
Paid Ads? |
How They Run It |
| Summers PHC |
Carroll Media (AI lead gen) |
$15,000-$50,000+ |
Very High |
AI-powered lead finding, print ads in NWI Times, high school sports sponsorships |
| King Heating |
5Fold Marketing (home services) |
$10,000-$30,000+ |
Very High |
TV commercials, tracks every call from ad to completed job, $14 back for every $1 spent on ads |
| Siemer |
EMSC (Chicago SEO/PPC) |
$3,000-$8,000 |
High |
Podium reviews, NitroPack speed, Google Tag Manager |
| Earl's Heating |
No agency found — uses ServiceTitan |
$2,000-$6,000 |
High |
ServiceTitan call tracking (DNI), conversion pixel, Facebook tracking |
| Lansing Heating |
MTA360 (HVAC specialist) |
$2,000-$5,000 |
High |
HVAC-specific agency endorsed by Carrier, Trane, Bryant |
| Meyer's |
NUVEW (Crown Point, IN) |
$1,500-$5,000 |
Moderate |
Microsoft Clarity analytics, local NWI agency |
| POPA |
None detected (likely DIY) |
$500-$2,000 |
Low |
Basic WordPress, Google Tag Manager only |
| ▶ Collins |
None |
$0 |
None |
GBP managed by SEO pro, website redesign planned |
| STAT HVAC |
None |
$0-$500 |
Minimal |
Websites.com basic builder — no analytics at all |
💰
What Do Google Ads Cost in This Market?
These are industry benchmark numbers for what competitors are typically paying — not quotes or proposals. The average cost per click for HVAC keywords in this market is about $9 per click. Emergency keywords like "24-hour AC repair" can cost $30-$50+ per click. Most small HVAC companies spend $3,000-$5,000/month on ad spend alone. A more affordable option: Google Local Services Ads cost $25-$85 per lead with about a 55% close rate. Important: These figures are the ad spend only — what goes directly to Google. Running ads also requires ongoing professional management (strategy, setup, optimization, reporting, and adjustments), which is a separate cost on top of the ad budget. Most of the competitors listed in this report are paying an agency to manage their campaigns in addition to the ad spend itself.
💥
King's Agency Documented 1,400% ROI
5Fold Marketing published a case study showing they achieved $14 back for every $1 King spends on ads. They track every phone call from ad click to completed job using ServiceTitan. King also runs TV commercials — the only NWI HVAC competitor advertising on television.
💡
Opportunity: Facebook Ads Are Underused in This Market
Only Summers and King appear to run Facebook/Instagram ads consistently. Industry benchmarks show Facebook leads typically cost $20-$75 for service calls and $40-$200 for installations in ad spend. These numbers reflect what goes to the platform — professional campaign management is an additional investment. That said, this channel is wide open in NWI since most competitors aren't using it.
Confirmed Advertising & Community Marketing
What we were able to verify competitors are actually running right now — ads, sponsorships, and community involvement:
Summers PHC
Most Aggressive Advertiser
Heavy Spend
Facebook Ads930 leads in 90 days, seen 877K times, ~$1 per click
Print AdsActive in NWI Times
Direct MailValpak coupons (active)
SponsorshipsVNN high school sports (5+ schools)
CommunityFood drive (99K+ items), 25K water bottles
Facebook AdsPrintDirect MailSponsorshipsCause Marketing
King Heating
Multi-Channel + TV
Heavy Spend
TV CommercialsChicago stations (tracked on iSpot.tv)
Google AdsConfirmed via 5Fold — 1,400% ROI
Social AdsProfessional photo/video campaigns
CRMServiceTitan: tracks every lead by source
ExpansionAcquired Hollaway-Meyer's in Hammond (since 1927)
TV CommercialsGoogle AdsSocial AdsAcquisitions
POPA Heating
Strong Local Advertiser
Active
Print AdsNWI Times — "Basketball Mania" deal (March 2026)
FacebookSeasonal campaigns tied to March Madness
Sponsorships2026 Home & Remodeling Expo (Kids Zone)
CommunityHumane Indiana (ongoing), American Legion HVAC donation, "Owl" art project
Print AdsFacebook CampaignsCause MarketingExpo Sponsor
Williamson Heating
Lead Generation Focus
Active
DiscountsMilitary & senior discounts on service/installation
SEOCity pages for every town in service area
Contest/Lead GenMilitary/Senior Discounts
Siemer HVAC
Promotion-Driven
Moderate
CommunityChamber of Commerce, local sports/churches, Nextdoor Favorite 2022
Digital Score74/100 (BuzzBoard)
Website PromosChamber MemberNextdoor Favorite
Meyer's Companies
Print Advertiser
Moderate
Print AdsNWI Times display ads (confirmed)
DirectoryNWI Times business listing (active)
Content~300+ blog posts (biggest content producer)
Print AdsBlog Content
Earl's, STAT HVAC, True Quality, and Polar have no confirmed paid advertising campaigns. They rely on organic search, directory listings, and word-of-mouth. Facebook Ad Library requires manual browser access to verify active social ads — check here.
AI Search: Where You Show Up Now & Where You Could Grow
More homeowners are using Google's AI answers, ChatGPT, and Siri to find contractors. Here's where Collins stands today:
✅
Collins Shows Up in AI Results for Highland
When someone asks Google AI or ChatGPT "best HVAC company Highland Indiana," Collins is mentioned and recommended with positive language about honest advice, great service, and fair pricing. Your service pages are getting picked up.
Where You Show Up Now (7 Cities You Serve)
Collins appears in AI search results when homeowners search for HVAC services in Highland. That's your home base, and the AI tools recognize you there thanks to your strong reviews and service pages.
The other 6 cities (Schererville, Munster, St. John, Dyer, Griffith, Hammond) — Collins doesn't show up in AI answers yet. Competitors with more city-specific content (Siemer, Illiana, True Quality) are the ones AI tools recommend there.
What's Available If You Want to Grow
AI search is still new — only 2–3 competitors in all of NW Indiana are set up well for it. Most are in the same boat as Collins. The companies showing up are the ones with a dedicated page for each city and answers to common homeowner questions on their site.
The new website rebuild already includes city pages and FAQ content. That alone will put Collins ahead of most competitors for AI search — no extra work needed beyond what's already planned.
⚠️
Honest Market Context: The Window Won't Stay Open Forever
Private equity-backed companies (like King Heating, which has acquired 7 businesses) are expanding into NW Indiana with maintenance plans, 24/7 availability, and big ad budgets. The window for solo operators to establish a strong online presence gets smaller each year. This isn't a scare tactic — it's the trend. The sooner Collins shows up in AI results across all 7 cities, the harder it is for new competitors to push you out.
Why AI Search Matters
62% of HVAC searches on phones now show a Google AI answer at the very top. Those AI answers get most of the clicks — and the businesses mentioned get most of the calls.
42% fewer people are clicking on regular website results since Google started showing AI answers. If you're not in the AI answer, many customers won't see you at all.
AI Search Readiness: How Competitors Compare
What makes a website show up in AI answers: business info Google can read, pages for each city, answers to common questions, and helpful articles.
| Company |
Business Info Google Can Read |
City Pages |
Q&A Content |
Helpful Articles |
AI Readiness |
| Siemer |
Full — best in area |
27 cities |
— |
~60 posts |
High |
| Illiana Heating |
Full — very detailed |
15 cities |
— |
Active |
High |
| True Quality |
Full |
10+ cities |
— |
Educational |
Moderate-High |
| King Heating |
Basic |
35+ locations |
— |
~200+ posts |
Moderate |
| Earl's |
Basic |
Some |
— |
~15-20 posts |
Moderate |
| Meyer's |
Basic |
20+ cities |
— |
~300+ posts |
Moderate |
| Williamson |
Unknown |
Every city |
— |
— |
Moderate |
| POPA |
Basic |
— |
— |
— |
Low |
| ▶ Collins |
Has it on rebuilt pages |
6 cities |
— |
— |
Low-Moderate |
| STAT HVAC |
None |
— |
— |
— |
Very Low |
🚀
Most Competitors Aren't Ready Either — That's the Opportunity
Only 2–3 companies in all of NW Indiana show up well in AI search. Everyone else is in the same position as Collins. The website rebuild (city pages + Q&A content + business info Google can read) will put Collins ahead of most competitors for AI search automatically.
Competitive Scorecard
A quick side-by-side grading of Collins vs. the top competitors across the factors that matter most for winning local HVAC customers:
| Factor |
Collins |
Siemer |
POPA |
Earl's |
Williamson |
| Google Reviews |
D (112) |
A+ (2,021) |
A (1,355) |
A (1,369) |
C (137) |
| New Reviews per Month |
D |
A+ (Podium) |
B |
B |
C |
| Google Local Pack |
B (7/10 Highland searches, while open) |
A |
A+ |
A |
C |
| Google Search Results |
B+ (81%) |
B (54%) |
C (12%) |
C+ (31%) |
A (88%) |
| Google Business Profile |
A (weekly posts) |
A |
B |
B+ |
C |
| Website Quality |
B |
A |
B |
A- |
B |
| Website Content |
C (17 pages, no blog) |
A (50+ pages, blog) |
C (15 pages) |
B+ (30+ pages, blog) |
B (30+ pages) |
| City Pages |
B (6 cities) |
A+ (27 cities) |
D (none) |
D (none) |
A+ (all cities) |
| Advertising |
D (minimal) |
B+ (EMSC agency) |
C |
B (ServiceTitan) |
C |
| Social Media |
D (FB only) |
B+ (FB + IG) |
B (FB + IG + YT) |
C (FB only) |
D |
| Reputation (rating) |
A (4.8, A+ BBB) |
A+ (4.9, A+ BBB) |
A+ (4.9, A+ BBB) |
A (4.8, A+ BBB) |
A (4.9) |
| Trust & Differentiators |
A (owner-operated, repairs-first) |
A (Carrier President's Award) |
A (58 yrs, Trane Distinguished) |
A (50 yrs, Trane Specialist) |
B (family-owned) |
Grades are relative to NWI market competitors only, not national benchmarks.
What's at Stake: Revenue Opportunity
Rough estimates of what closing the competitive gaps could mean in additional revenue, based on industry averages for the NWI market:
| Opportunity |
What It Takes |
Est. Additional Revenue/Year |
Timeline |
| Breaking into the Local Pack (Highland) |
250+ reviews, GBP improvements, review velocity |
$18,000 - $48,000 |
6-12 months |
| Ranking in Schererville & Munster |
Stronger city pages, targeted content, local signals |
$24,000 - $60,000 |
6-12 months |
| Improving installation keyword rankings |
Strengthen existing install pages with content & reviews |
$24,000 - $48,000 |
3-6 months |
| Google Local Services Ads |
$1,000-$2,500/mo ad budget + management fees |
$36,000 - $72,000 |
Immediate |
| Review generation system |
Podium/NiceJob ($300-$500/mo), ask after every job |
Compounds all other gains |
Ongoing |
Estimates based on average HVAC ticket values ($3,000-$8,000 for installations, $150-$500 for repairs) and typical conversion rates for local search. Actual results depend on capacity, pricing, and close rate.
Service Area Demographics
Who lives in each city Collins serves. Income, homeownership, and housing age are the three factors that matter most for HVAC demand. The older the housing stock and the higher the homeownership rate, the more HVAC work is available.
Top Target
St. John ~26,100
Highest Value
Median Income$127,449 – $131,467
Homeownership97 – 98%
Median Home Age~2005
Med. Home Value$406,300
Seniors (65+)16.3%
Growth+27% since 2020
Top Target
Munster ~23,700
High Value
Median Income$105,764
Homeownership86.1%
Median Home Age1969 – 1972
Med. Home Value$312,000
Seniors (65+)17.9%
HVAC UrgencyHigh — aging 1960s–70s stock
Top Target
Dyer ~16,500
High Value
Median Income$101,183
Homeownership90%
Median Home Age1991
Med. Home Value$322,200
Seniors (65+)22.4% (highest)
HVAC UrgencyModerate — 1990s systems aging out
Core Market
Schererville ~29,600
High Value
Median Income$86,020
Homeownership79.8%
Median Home Age1988
Med. Home Value$325,000 – $385,000
Seniors (65+)19.4%
HVAC UrgencyHigh — 1980s systems in replacement zone
Home Base
Highland ~23,500
Mid Value
Median Income$76,219
Homeownership77.2%
Median Home Age1963 – 1976
Med. Home Value$240,000 – $260,000
Seniors (65+)18.2%
HVAC UrgencyHigh — oldest housing after Hammond
Core Market
Griffith ~16,200
Mid Value
Median Income$76,009
Homeownership72.4%
Median Home Age1964 – 1966
Med. Home Value$221,028
Seniors (65+)~14 – 17%
HVAC UrgencyHigh — heavily 1960s construction
Volume Market
Hammond ~77,100
Lower Value / High Volume
Median Income$53,950
Homeownership62.5%
Median Home Age1952 (oldest)
Med. Home Value$159,870 – $185,000
Seniors (65+)12.1%
Hispanic Pop.40.9%
Addressable Market: ~60,500 Owner-Occupied Households
Across all 7 cities, there are approximately 60,500 owner-occupied homes — these are the households that hire their own HVAC contractor. Hammond has the most total homes (~18,400 owner-occupied) but the lowest incomes and highest renter rate. Munster, Schererville, Dyer, and St. John are the highest-value targets: high incomes, high homeownership, and homeowners who pay for quality work without shopping purely on price.
The weighted median household income across the service area is roughly $82,000. The weighted median age is ~42. This is a middle-class to upper-middle-class suburban market where trust and reliability matter more than being the cheapest option.
Customer Personas
Who is actually calling Collins? These profiles are built from the demographic data above. They describe the real people making HVAC decisions in NW Indiana.
Primary: The Established Homeowner
Ages 45–60 • Highland, Munster, Schererville, Dyer
Household income: $75,000 – $110,000. Owns a 3-bedroom ranch or split-level built between 1965 and 1990. Has lived there 10–20+ years. One or both work in healthcare, manufacturing, trades, logistics, or education. May commute to Chicago.
Their furnace is 12–18 years old. They know it is getting old but put off replacing it until something breaks. They call for a repair first. If the repair estimate is high, they think about replacement.
What they want: Someone who shows up on time, is honest about what the system actually needs, gives a clear price upfront, and does not try to sell them something they do not need. They will check Google reviews and ask a neighbor before calling.
How they find Collins: Google search ("furnace repair Highland IN"), Google Maps, neighbor recommendation, or seeing the van in the neighborhood.
Calls on the phone
Checks Google reviews
Price-aware, not price-driven
Hates high-pressure sales
Secondary: The New Suburban Family
Ages 32–42 • St. John, southern Schererville, newer Dyer
Household income: $100,000 – $135,000. Owns a 4-bedroom home built 2005–2018, around 2,500–3,000 sq ft. Both partners are professionals — one likely commutes to Chicago or works remote/hybrid.
Their HVAC is builder-grade equipment approaching 15–20 years old. They are noticing higher energy bills and efficiency issues. They are interested in upgrading to better equipment and may be open to air quality products (purifiers, humidifiers) if presented naturally.
What they want: Professionalism, cleanliness (shoe covers, cleanup), and clear communication. They will compare 2–3 contractors before deciding. They read multiple Google reviews carefully and may check Nextdoor or local Facebook groups.
How they find Collins: Google search ("best HVAC contractor near me"), reading reviews carefully, Nextdoor recommendations, or local Facebook groups.
Researches online first
Compares 2–3 contractors
Open to upgrades / IAQ
Values professionalism
Tertiary: The Hammond Homeowner
Ages 35–50 • Hammond
Household income: $45,000 – $60,000. Owns (or inherited) a 2–3 bedroom bungalow or ranch built in the 1940s–1960s. May be bilingual (English/Spanish). The HVAC system is old and breaks down frequently.
Price is the primary factor. They will get multiple quotes and repair as long as possible before replacing. They value honesty above all — "Just tell me what it really needs." More likely to ask family and friends for recommendations than to search online.
Important note: Hammond has the largest population (77,100) but the lowest conversion potential due to high renter rates (37.5%) and lower incomes. Collins should serve Hammond customers well but should not over-invest marketing budget here versus Munster, Schererville, Dyer, and St. John.
Price is #1 factor
Repairs over replacement
Word-of-mouth driven
Largest city by population
The Review Gap: Collins vs. POPA
This is the single biggest factor keeping Collins out of the Google Local Pack. The gap is not a small difference — it is a 10x difference.
POPA Heating & Cooling
★ 4.9 • Est. 1968 • Highland, IN
▶ Collins Heating & Cooling
★ 4.8 • Est. 2005 • Highland, IN
~10x gap
Collins needs roughly 1,000 more reviews to match POPA
Why this matters: Google uses review count + recency as one of the main factors for deciding who gets into the Local Pack (the top 3 businesses shown with the map). POPA has been collecting reviews for decades. Collins' reviews dropped off for about 2 years, and the gap widened.
The plan: NiceJob is now in place to automate review requests after every job. Siemer grew from ~1,400 to 2,021 reviews in 12–18 months using Podium. At a similar pace, Collins could reach 250+ reviews within 12 months — enough to start appearing in the Local Pack for some searches.
Realistic target: Collins will likely never match POPA's total count (they have a 16-year head start and a larger operation). But 250–300 reviews with a 4.8+ rating and consistent monthly velocity is enough to compete for Local Pack placement, especially combined with a faster website and stronger content.
When Customers Can Find You on Google Maps
Google only shows your business in map results during your listed hours. Outside those hours, customers see your competitors instead.
29%
of the week you're visible
Collins is listed as open 49 hours/week. There are 168 hours in a week. That means you're invisible for 119 hours every week.
|
12a | 2a | 4a | 6a |
8a | 10a | 12p | 2p |
4p | 6p | 8p | 10p |
| Mon | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Tue | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Wed | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Thu | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Fri | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Sat | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✓ | ✓ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| Sun | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
Visible
Invisible to searchers
Growth option: Extending your listed Google hours — even with voicemail after hours — increases your visibility at zero cost. You don't have to answer the phone at 9pm. You just have to be listed as open so Google shows you.
Example: Listing 7am–9pm Mon–Sat would go from 49 to 84 hours/week — a 71% increase in visibility.
Current Website: Site Audit Summary
Last audited March 31, 2026. Score improved after page updates — but the platform is still holding things back.
Score Improved After Updates
Brand violations fixed, city pages rebuilt with real content and schema, contact page added. The slow platform and 3 remaining thin pages are still dragging the score down. The new site build will fix that.
❌ Problems With the Current Site (Why We're Rebuilding)
- Every page loads tons of unnecessary code — makes the site slow on phones
- 32 extra files load on every page that do nothing — slows everything down
- 9 of 15 pages Google knows about are being ignored — Google won't show them to anyone
- 6 city pages have no business info that Google can read — Google doesn't know what they're about
- "100% Satisfaction Guarantee" shows up in Google for heating repair — Collins doesn't make that claim
- "Our team" on Munster and Schererville pages — Collins is a solo operator
- No About page, no AC maintenance page, no clear page-by-page navigation
- City pages have barely any content — Google refuses to show pages with so little on them
✅ What's Working Well
- Rebuilt service pages have business info Google can read (name, services, ratings)
- Strong content on service pages: real answers to real questions, reviews, clear "call now" prompts
- Each rebuilt page has a clear headline Google understands
- Phone number is visible and tappable at the top, middle, and bottom of rebuilt pages
- The writing sounds like a real person — not a marketing template
- Site is secure and pages are set up correctly for Google
- Service pages link to each other so customers can browse easily
- Google Business Profile is well-maintained with weekly posts
Why We're Rebuilding: Before & After
Current Site
Slow
Loads 32 extra files on every page • sluggish on phones
➔
New Site
7x Faster
Same content, 7x less bloat • loads fast on any phone
Why This Matters
The current site builder loads a mountain of unnecessary junk on every page — stuff nobody needs and nobody sees. Google punishes slow sites, especially on phones. 46% of your visitors are on their phone (from your actual Google Analytics data, 2024–2025). That number is probably lower than it should be — people on phones are giving up before the site finishes loading.
The new site delivers the same content, same look, but 7 times faster. Faster site = higher on Google = more calls. When the site actually loads fast on a phone, expect that mobile number to climb past 60%.
The content is already written and proven. It just needs a site that doesn't slow it down. Target: May 2026.
Accessibility & Design Notes
The demographic data tells us who will be using the new website. These are the design requirements that follow from that data.
👤
22% of Dyer Residents Are Seniors (65+) — 19.4% in Schererville
These are two of the highest-value markets in the service area. Dyer has the highest senior population of any city Collins serves. Seniors are more likely to prioritize comfort, reliability, and trust over price — ideal Collins customers. But they need a website they can actually use.
📱
Design Requirements for This Audience (Ages 40–60, 16% Seniors)
Font size: 18px minimum body text. No tiny gray text on white backgrounds. The median age across the service area is 42 — readability without zooming is mandatory.
Contrast: WCAG AA minimum (4.5:1). Aim for AAA (7:1) where practical.
Touch targets: 44x44px minimum for all buttons, phone numbers, and form fields. Critical for the 40–60 age group on mobile.
Phone number: Tappable, visible without scrolling, on every page. This audience calls — they do not fill out web forms as a first action.
Navigation: 5–7 items maximum. No complex mega-menus. Labels like "Heating," "Cooling," "Air Quality," "Reviews," "Contact."
No autoplay video or animations that could distract or confuse older users.
🌐
Spanish Welcome Line for Hammond (40.9% Hispanic Population)
The website does not need full Spanish translation — the vast majority of Hispanic households in Lake County report English as their primary language. However, a brief Spanish-language line in the footer and on the contact page is a smart welcoming gesture: "Se habla español — llame al (219) 924-7423". This costs nothing and signals respect for Hammond-area customers.
Mobile-First Is Non-Negotiable
Expect 60–70% of traffic from mobile devices. Lower-income households in Hammond are more likely to be smartphone-only (no desktop/broadband), making the mobile experience even more critical. Every page, every form, every phone number must work flawlessly on a phone.
The primary customer persona (ages 45–60) is searching on their phone, often during a heating or cooling problem. If the site is slow or hard to use on mobile, they call the next company in the search results. The new custom theme is being built mobile-first.
Data Sources & Methodology
Search Rankings
- Google organic search results — 26 keyword/city searches performed March 23, 2026
- Business-hours ranking check — 28 keywords, March 31, 2026 at 10:48 AM CT
- 5 keyword groups: AC installation, furnace repair, HVAC contractor, AC repair, furnace installation
- 7 cities: Highland, Munster, Griffith, Schererville, Dyer, St. John, Hammond
- Top 10 organic results captured per search
- Historical ranking data from SERP tracker (March 2, 2026 baseline — 32 keywords)
Review & Reputation Data
- Google Business Profiles — direct review counts
- Birdeye review aggregator (verified counts, March 2026)
- Yelp business listings
- BBB.org business profiles
- Angi / HomeAdvisor listings
- Facebook business pages
- Nextdoor business pages
Competitor Websites
- Direct website audits of 10+ competitor sites (March 2026)
- Page counts estimated from navigation and sitemaps
- Technology detection via source code analysis
- Schema markup verification
- Specials pages checked live March 23, 2026
Business Verification
- Google Maps business listings
- BBB business profiles and complaint records
- Public property records (Lake County, IN)
- State licensing databases
- Manufacturer dealer directories (Carrier, Trane, Bryant)
Review & Reputation Tools
- Birdeye review aggregator — verified review counts (popa-heating-cooling-164830902284832, siemer-heating-cooling-165354775497101, earls-heating-air-conditioning-165416055195445, king-heating-cooling-plumbing-159124755127167)
- Podium review tool detected on siemerinc.com/review/
- Trane dealer directory (trane.com/residential/en/dealers/)
- Carrier dealer directory (carrier.com/residential/en/us/dealers/)
Social Media & Content
- Facebook business pages (follower counts, recommendation rates)
- Instagram profiles (@siemerhvac, @kingheating, @popa_hvac)
- YouTube channels (POPA: @popaheatingcooling)
- Blog post counts from sitemap/navigation analysis
- King Heating TV ads tracked via iSpot.tv
- Job postings via Glassdoor, Indeed, company career pages
Technical Analysis
- Website load times measured via HTTP response timing
- Page sizes measured from initial HTML response
- Domain registration dates via WHOIS lookup (who.is)
- CMS/platform detection via source code analysis
- Schema markup verification via page source